• Home

  • Recent News

    • Earlier News
  • Downloads

    • Bird Checklists
    • Non-bird checklists
    • IUCN Red List
    • Links & Reports
  • Birding sites

    • Regions
    • Northern region
    • Central region (Dubai)
    • East Coast (Fujairah)
    • Abu Dhabi area
    • Al Ain area
    • Western Region
    • Offshore region
  • Key Species

  • Pelagics

  • ID Problems

    • Squacco Heron vs Indian Pond Heron
    • Pallid Harrier vs Montagu's Harrier
    • Common Snipe vs Pin-tailed Snipe
    • Large gulls in the UAE
    • Caspian Gull
    • Little Tern vs Saunders's Tern
    • Daurian Shrike vs Turkestan Shrike
    • The Lesser Whitethroat complex
    • The Chiffchaff complex
    • Semicollared vs European Pied Flycatcher
    • Richard's vs Blyth's Pipit
  • Photos

    • Bird photos
    • Mammal photos
    • Reptiles and amphibian photos
    • Damsel and dragonfly photos
    • Butterfly and moth photos
    • Insect photos
    • Spider and scorpion photos
    • Marine wildlife photos
  • EBRC

    • About EBRC
    • Report a rarity
    • Description species
  • Club 300

  • Guiding

  • OSME

  • Contact

  • Forum

    • Members
  • More

    Use tab to navigate through the menu items.
    To see this working, head to your live site.
    • Categories
    • All Posts
    • My Posts
    Vlad Sladariu Negulescu
    Sep 24, 2019

    Shorebirds from Khor al-Beida, august

    in Identification problems

    Hi all,


    I have a checklist that's been giving me headaches for almost two months - too much heat glare, too many small waders... so I've decided to get rid of it and move on :) I would be grateful for any opinion you can provide on the photos below (even if you think the photo is too bad for id).


    1. sand plover: lesser vs greater. I've looked at these until I got dizzy :)

    I think greater:



    I think lesser:


    2. temmink's stint? or some kind of sandpiper? are the photos to bad to tell?



    3. little stint? almost sure of pics 3 and 4, but it's more orange than i've usually seen, so I want to double check.

    I changed my mind again about pic 2, now i think curlew sandpiper...






    4. dunlin? or curlew sandpiper?



    5. curlew? the bill seems a little short...



    thanks!

    2 comments
    0
    Mark Smiles
    Sep 27, 2019

    Most of your ID attempts are correct or pretty close. The first two sandplovers are indeed Greater & Lesser - Greater with the longer bill & greenish legs, Lesser shorter-billed and darker legs.


    Number 4 is a Curlew Sand - long thigh, hint of a supercilium and note how the bill tapers evenly to a fine tip, unlike the blunter tip of Dunlin.


    5 is trickier. It could be a Whimbrel, it appears to have a slight kink at the end of the bill, but I can't 100% rule out a juvenile Curlew from the quality of this image.


    Identifying species from heavy crops or heat-haze affected images is often subjective and not always subjective. Starting out, you may find it better to focus your attention on birds that are close enough to study to learn their differences rather than worrying about birds that are specks or blurs. Watch how they feed & behave - behaviour often gets overlooked when you're looking through a viewfinder. Once you have a few of the commoner species sorted, a lot of these species will become easier.

    0
    Vlad Sladariu Negulescu
    Sep 27, 2019

    Thanks a lot Mark, this is very helpful! Especially since I could not find comparative descriptions (of, for example, Dunlin vs Curlew Sand vs Broad billed sand). I do have a wader guide book on my reading list, hoping that will also help.


    I’ll follow your advice and focus more on behavior of closer birds than shape of distant ones. So far I was going for list completion as a priority - sorry that led me to ask for a lot of help.


    Cheers,

    0
    2 comments
    • twitter

    © 2020/21 Tommy Pedersen & Ahmed Al Ali
    Created with Wix.com